No, we do not have a crossover between pastries and stationery (though I wish that combination will happen more often); my planner pick of 2018 is named after a dessert. I have been dragging my feet on talking about this planner, partly because it is not as accessible as Hobonichi, Midori, Maruman, and other arrays of Japanese planner; nonetheless, Brownie was voted by users in Japan as number 2 planner just right after Hobonichi. So what is the allure?
Two features jumped out at me after reading various unboxing and reviews posts shared by stationery community (mostly from Asia): the paper was described as baby’s bottoms and the planner format accommodates those who track different tasks/projects. Since the size is comparable to other planners I have used in the past, Brownie appeared to be a viable switch. It is available in A6 (same as Hobonichi Techo) and A5 Slim (a slightly taller but narrower version of Hobonichi cousin). Each measures 105 x 148 x 9mm (4.13 x 5.83 x .35 inch) and 130 x 210 x 9mm (5.11 x 8.27 x .35 inch) respectively.
The planner comes with a polyurethane cover that protects the book from being soiled. Similar to Hobonichi’s basic cover on cover, it has two inner pockets that are spacious enough for ID and other knickknacks. The cover is plushy to touch and is washable, but soils fairly easily especially for the lighter color ones. Every year, Brownie releases cover with different colors, usually based on a theme. The one for 2019 is Japanese traditional colors, as seen here.
Here comes the interesting tidbit about Brownie– it comes with its own usage instruction (only for A5 Slim). Even though the sample pages are in Japanese, the visual cues give new and returning users ideas on how to use the planner.
The first thing I did immediately is to touch the paper. Its incredibly smooth surface adds an air of luxury to this aesthetically simple planner. The texture of the paper reminds me of Midori notebooks/planners and Rhodia pad, but amazingly it is not bulky. For a 14-month planner to be only 9mm (.35 inch) thick is truly extraordinary. Some paper may increase in volume after usage, but after one year the planner is not visibly bulkier. The ivory-colored paper are easy to the eyes yet not dull the vibrancy in colors. Even though I received the planner in early November of 2017, I could not resist to test out the paper with media that comes to mind. So far, the paper is highly resistant. There is no show-through or feathering; it does buckle slightly with a lightwash of watercolor.
To describe paper in Brownie as buttery is no exaggeration. In addition to the smooth texture the paper is cream in color. The picture below will show where it falls on the creaminess spectrum:
In the competition of “who is the fairest of all,” Brownie will definitely be eliminated. To my eyes, they are even a tint darker than Midori Notebook Diary. Despite that, the hue of the paper did not absorb or diminish vibrancy of colors.
Similar to Hobonichi Techo, Brownie has grid-ruled pages for its monthly and weekly sections. Not all of us have ant-sized, super neat writing and it seems that Brownie’s grid size is more accommodating to most mortals than Hobonichi, as shown above.
The encounter between the user and the planner is interactive, in ways that the aesthetics of the planner appeal to the users and the layout of the planner can dictate how it will be used. The inherent risk is at times, the fitting period may last longer than expected and at times, the layout just does not mesh with user’s styles. Besides the doom and gloom, the layout can also inspire new ways of recording one’s life and tasks.
The first section is a two-year calendar spread. To me, this can be an apt section to chronicle important events or due date, as the spread is designed to give that bird’s eye view of the current and following year. The way I utilize this spread is much smaller in scale; these pages are dedicated to keep track of vacation and sick time I have used. The open layout can give users a quick glimpse of what they are tracking, without fumbling pages.
In most planners I have used, the monthly section is almost always fashioned in grids. While I understand the larger grid format provides an overview to upcoming events, I usually find these grids rather restrictive, even though I have tiny writing. Brownie monthly section answers to my quandary (if you would call it that). In the monthly section, you can always see something that is particular to Brownie: the three-column set up.
Most of us use planners to track multiple trajectories in life and these three-columns are meant to facilitate that. It offers a viable alternative to toting multiple planners and potential solutions to manage multiple projects, deadlines, and commitments. As one may notice, the dates are printed both horizontally and vertically. Yes, you can use entire planner in either direction to visually distinguish various activities you wish to record. The grid paper with different date orientation also make habit tracking easier, as one can devise a variety of charts with this combination.
Here is an example on how I use the monthly spread for the first three months. One section tracks the duration of my exercise routine; the middle denotes any work related; the left records upcoming bill due dates. In some examples I have found online, users forego text and dedicate the entire spread to track project, habits, or personal spending.
The Weekly section formatted similarly to the monthly section. A small calendar locates on the upper left hand corner, with the current week circled.
The border that demarcates date also serves as time axle, in 24-hour time. Along the time line, each grid represents 30 minutes which I find marking duration of appointment a lot easier and to an extent, a more realistic representation of time elapsed. Since the time axle is printed vertically, it naturally guides the users to record their time-specific engagement in the same manner, which makes the appointments stand out from other scribbles on the page.
Here is how a typical day looks on a weekly spread. Because the planner can be used both vertically and horizontally, there is ample space for me to keep track of weekly projects and their progress. Given the nature of my position most projects last about a week or just a tad longer. By drawing arrows, it gives me an idea how long I roughly spend on projects in addition to existing tasks. Different colors are used to denote appointments of various nature.
Brownie is designed with project tracking in mind and this concept is particularly prominent in this yearly spread. Each column represents a month, with numbers of days in each month. This page can be useful for those who are managing projects with many moving pieces over long span of time.
It is obvious I did not use these pages as they were originally intended, as I do not have projects that usually last longer than a week or two. Instead, I use this section to keep a record of which watercolor pencils that are in my possession. It comes in handy especially when I tend to buy single pencils rather than sets.
Overall, Brownie paper takes water fairly well, besides slight buckling. No seep through to the next page.
Similar to Hobonichi Techo, Brownie also has 10- blank pages after the planning section. I use these pages to jot down books I would like to read and knitting patterns that I am interested. Even though there are communities like Goodreads and Ravelry, I am still partial to jotting down anything that caught my eyes partly because the act of writing helps with remembering.
Followed by information pages.
Similar to most Japanese planners, owner’s information page is the last on a planner. Even though I never use this section, it gives me the feeling that trust still exists around us, albeit in small way. Planners, for some, are quintessence and integral to their lives.
In addition to 5 note pages in the back of the planner, Brownies also has a separate booklet nested in the back cover. Similar to Hobonichi’s Download City, Brownies offers a variety of additional templates that users can print and paste onto these free pages. The booklet can be looked at as an extension of space for the planner, as for some it may be a bit limited compared to other planners.
Even though the paper is similar to Midori, Brownies remains fairly slim even after a year of use.
Even though Brownie planner does not have all the customization options as Hobonichi, after almost a year of use it has an air of understated elegance. The paper quality and overall feel is impeccable– feeling almost as an upgrade to Tomoe paper, as the see-through effect is not as obvious. The format is definiltey more project driven yet flexible enough to anyone to adapt to their preference and liking. Brownie in a way, allows users to present pertinent information in different manners, let it be text, graph, or something in between. The capability of being able to use the planner both horizontally and vertically may seem challenging at first, but I found it useful to separate tasks of different natures visually, while keeping everything in one book. Compare to Hobonichi original or Weeks, Brownie’s writing real estate may appear to be limited, but with the enclosed booklet and versatality in orientation, the space can be maximized. With all elements combined, Brownie truly embraces its 365/1 logo, embossed on the cover. One book can captured all.
Unlike Hobonichi, Brownie planner can only be purchased from oversea retailers. Plain Stationery, Homeware and Cafe in Taiwan does ship internationally (approximate shipping fee is $10 USD). The official Brownie website does have a store front; however, it only ships within Japan.
How do you like a multi-tasking planner?
4 thoughts on “Brownie planner A5 Slim”
Such an interesting planner, Shangching! The horizontal and vertical formats for the week at a glance is especially fascinating. I’ve never seen a planner that’s so responsive to how the user feels like using it. It sounds like you’re really enjoying it!
I am glad that I stuck to my gut instinct and try out Brownie for the year. The interchanging horizontal and vertical format works out better than I expected. Too bad that it is not as widely distributed so more people can try it out.
Thank you for stopping by!
What a great planner. I never heard of it before. Thank you for the review. What a shame it doesn’t seem to have a daily section.
How it can be used both vertically and horizontally is quite clever. I guess with a daily section it would be quite a Techo contender for many users.
Happy new year! I am glad I took the dive on Brownie. It is definitely more minimalist than Hobonichi Techo and Weeks. Personally I am relieved that there is no daily section, since I am just horrible utilizing those pages. My guilt was assuaged, so to speak, with this planner. One thing I do miss from Hononichi Weeks is the opposing grid-ruled page where one can scribble relevant information on. Probably because of that, I went back to Hobonichi Weeks for 2019. What is your set-up like this year?